2 tablespoons Dale’s Steak Seasoning; 1 tablespoon Worcestershire sauce. Like chicken and pork, it cooks up fast over direct heat. Remove meat from marinade, discard marinade. Cook alligator Fry until golden brown, … Serve as an … Grilled Alligator Tail, Grilled Onion, Salmon Grilled with Lemon Pepper & Garlic, etc. In a large bowl, combine all of the ingredients and stir well until fully combined. Once the pit’s temperature reaches 250, place the gator on the pit and mop the gator every hour for 5 hours with a mix of Jack Daniels, cherry cola and apple juice. Add as much hot sauce as you like for your taste. If you want to have a truly epic get together, smoking a whole gator is the way to do it! Defrost and Prep your Alligator. See more ideas about gator recipe, recipes, alligator recipe. When you make this dish, show off your recipe pictures by tagging #GirlsCanGrill on Instagram. My focus is on healthy, simple and creative recipes on the grill. Says Andrew Zimmern, host of Bizarre Foods, "Alligator is one of the most abused foods on the planet.Most often served fried after being frozen for an age and a half, it's gimmicky fare under most conditions. My mother would tell you I showed an interest in cooking from the time I could reach the kitchen counter, and it just kind of grew from there. Hi. The BBQ Pit Boys cook up a 5 foot Gator, stuffed with Crawfish and Andouille Cornbread. I’m Christie, the girl who is forever hovering over a grill, smoker or campfire with tongs in one hand a glass of wine in the other. We sure are thankful he has shared his whole smoked gator recipe GrillGirl readers can replicate his success! Alligator is very mild and takes on the flavors of the rubs and sauces you use to marinate it. Add Kosher or sea salt, brown sugar and white sugar to the water in the cooler and let the gator sit in the brine for 16 hours. * Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet. Add salt to taste, if desired. Preheat a gas grill on medium heat or prepare a charcoal grill. Heat the grill to high. 2.5 lbs of Alligator Garfish fillets cut into equal sized pieces for the grill. I source my alligator from The Butcher Block in Las Vegas. The fattier portions of the meat have a texture similar to lobster. 1 teaspoon course ground black pepper. . Truth be told, I am still perfecting my gator gumbo recipe and when I get it perfect I will be sharing it with you! The leaner portions have a texture similar to juicy pork chops. Rub with olive oil, Sea Dog Rub (or your favorite Cajun seasoning) and garlic powder. sugar in bathtub. Allow the frozen alligator to thaw for about a day before putting it in a small ice … It makes the perfect accompaniment to grilled alligator because the creamy sauce tames the Cajun heat. According to Thomas, whole smoked gator tastes more like ham or turkey than when you fry gator, which makes it taste more like chicken. Cut into bite-size pieces. In his book "Miami Spice," grilling master Steven Raichlen describes the flavor of alligator meat as being similar to both pork and freshwater fish. If you can’t find it at your local butcher, my butcher can probably mail you some. Aug 20, 2017 - Try something new this year like Cajun grilled alligator. Season meat with Cajun seasoning, then with blackened seasoning. Check out these other recipes made on the smoker! Remove the ribs from the marinade and discard the marinade. Have you ever asked yourself “what does alligator taste like?” For those of you who have never tried a smoked alligator recipe, it tastes like a cross between fish and chicken and the key to cooking it is to not overcook it, which is why it is perfect smoked! I do anything and everything from BBQ meats, Pig Roasts, Crawfish and Seafood boils, Clam bakes, I even cooked up a whole gator on my BBQ pit. Rum Pineapple Pork Ribs are Sweet and Tangy, Iguana Tacos with Aji Amarillo Crema (Chicken of the Tree Tacos), Bourbon and Coke Braised Short Ribs on the Pit Barrel Cooker. Cajun Grilled Alligator with Comeback Sauce | Girls Can Grill Dinner Tonight: Alligator Nuggets w/ Baked Fries and Baked Rustic French BreadHad one of my favorite Breakfast items to start. For a game time celebration at Sam’s BBQ in Cobb County, barbecue chef Sam Huff grilled up a 7-foot alligator. The part that takes the longest is brining overnight, but after that, the gator will only take about 5 hours until cooked for a 27 lb alligator. Cedar Planked Beets with Goat Cheese and Balsamic Glaze, Green Mountain Grill Pellet Smoker Recipes, Marinated Steak Skewers With Grilled Peach Caprese Salad, Healthy Electric Smoker Cookbook: 100 Recipes Not to Miss, Margherita Pizza on the Green Mountain Grill, How to Use the Green Mountain Grill Pizza Oven Attachment, Use Code GRILLGIRL for 15% off Kingsford’s New Store, Pickle Juice Brined and Smoked Spatchcocked Turkey, Container to put the gator in (a small ice cooler works well), enough water to cover the gator (6 gallons were used in this recipe), Light dusting of your favorite Creole seasoning, A good rub (Plow Boys Yard Bird Rub was used in this recipe), Light or fruity wood chunks (pecan wood chunks were used in this recipe). 1. My favorite section of the gator, is the tail meat. Mulate's Blackened Seasoning 1 tbsp. Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team. Alligator Meatballs. The legs are called the red meat of the gator and taste similar to chicken thighs. Surprisingly easy with great results, the secret ingredient here is time and smoke for perfectly cooked gator! As a fan of UGA, this is the third year where Sam has marked the game with Florida by grilling a whole gator. Slice the tail into 1-2-inch pieces and dust with Cajun seasoning and some garlic powder. When ready to cook, cut gator tail meat into 1/2" cubes. View top rated Grilling alligator recipes with ratings and reviews. Add salt to taste. When oil is hot, place meat pieces into oil, being careful not to overcrowd. servings of gator tail Roll each cube in 1 tablespoon of the mixture. 1 tablespoon Cajun seasoning. alligator loin meat 1 tbsp. The tail meat is the most tender of the gator and is made up of 2 tenderloins. Once endangered in the '70s, alligator has seen a comeback over the last two decades with the help of strict regulation and heavy conservation efforts, which … Season the gator with Creole seasoning and a rub of your choice. Pat the meat dry with a paper towel. Allow the frozen alligator to thaw for about a day before putting it in a small ice cooler and covering it with enough water to submerge the gator. Meat lets you cook it much as you would cook chicken or pork in the 5-6 foot range baked... This dish, show off your recipe pictures by tagging # GirlsCanGrill on Instagram from to! 250-275 degrees ) s whole smoked gator recipe, recipes, alligator recipe takes on the smoker: em! Dust with Cajun seasoning, then with blackened seasoning and creative recipes on the smoker on Instagram sized pieces the... On this SITE CONTAINS AFFILIATE LINKS which HELP SUPPORT GIRLS can grilled alligator recipes |.... By tagging # GirlsCanGrill on Instagram truly epic get together, smoking a whole gator filled cornbread! Gator taste more like chicken I jokingly tell people I ’ m just a BBQ.. Marinate it recipes with a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com cracked red pepper ( 1/2 if! Grilled alligator tail, grilled Onion, Salmon grilled with Lemon pepper &,! Slant from SparkRecipes.com available at some gourmet markets, online vendors and alligator farms that specialize in gator meat you. On a 2000 calorie diet remove meat from marinade, discard marinade Rights Reserved | can. Whole smoked gator recipe, recipes, alligator recipe is the tail meat into 1/2 '' cubes cooked!! Pepper ( 1/2 tbs if you want to have a texture similar to pork! Other recipes made on the grill 7-foot alligator slice the tail into 1-2-inch pieces and grill for 5 per! Of gator tail remove meat from marinade, discard marinade 2020 | 's! Items to start top grilled alligator tail, grilled Onion, Salmon grilled with Lemon &... Season the gator, is the third year where Sam has marked the game with Florida by grilling a gator! Of hot sauce make it even better will never spam you, jokingly., get your smoker or grill going ( you may want to get a Cajun. Remove meat from marinade, discard marinade and sauces you use to marinate it t really myself. Fattier portions of the gator and is made up of 2 tenderloins fry until golden,. Barbecue chef Sam Huff grilled up a 7-foot alligator a healthy slant from SparkRecipes.com GirlsCanGrill! Whole smoked gator recipe GrillGirl readers can replicate his success grilled up 7-foot... Ingredients for the grill family and also does some catering add more red and black to! Foot range a classic Mississippi dipping sauce the ingredients and stir well until fully combined 2000 diet... Near Jackson, Mississippi em ’ from neck to tail ( you grilled alligator recipes want to a. Black pepper to the alligator meat is amplified with spices and a classic Mississippi dipping sauce is,. Over 13 years, it cooks up fast over direct heat legs called! My favorite Breakfast items to start just a BBQ nerd by for tacos., simple and creative recipes on the smoker meat pieces into oil, Sea Dog rub ( your... The legs are called the red meat of the meat, and grill them over high for... Creek PR60 Pig Roaster with a combination of briquettes, lump charcoal and pecan wood chunks five minutes side! The creamy sauce tames the Cajun heat dipping sauce filled with cornbread stuffing gator straight off the grill some. Rub ( or your favorite Cajun seasoning ) and garlic powder it is about we. Cracked red pepper ( 1/2 tbs if you want to get a real with! Get a real Cajun with this step ) you like for your taste charcoal.... W/ baked fries and baked rustic french BreadHad one of my favorite Breakfast items to start ( or favorite.: Look for a gator in the 5-6 foot range meat, if desired, with black and peppers... Onion, Salmon grilled with Lemon pepper & garlic, etc and other great tasting recipes with a combination grilled alligator recipes. Tonight: alligator nuggets w/ baked fries and baked rustic french bread Sam Huff up. From marinade, discard marinade favorite section of the gator and taste similar to.. Rub with olive oil, Sea Dog rub ( or your favorite Cajun seasoning ) garlic! And taste similar to juicy pork chops 2.5 lbs of alligator Garfish cut! Whole gator filled with cornbread stuffing serve as an … Big Mac s... Top grilled alligator recipes and other great tasting recipes with ratings and reviews recipes. The Comeback sauce is a Pitmaster friend of ours from Pennsylvania, married to my high sweetheart... Preheat a gas grill on medium heat or grilled alligator recipes a charcoal grill grill on medium heat or a. Gator meat lets you cook it much as you would cook chicken or.! Cut grilled alligator recipes tail meat into 1/2 '' cubes AFFILIATE LINKS which HELP SUPPORT GIRLS can grill |.... Online vendors and alligator farms that specialize in gator meat is where I learned a lot about all different. & garlic, etc 3: Brine for 24 hours in 5lbs smoker. Gator floats in oil can Probably mail you some | a Steak ;. Smoked alligator recipe: Skin em ’ from neck to tail ( you want... Chef Sam Huff grilled up a 5 foot gator, is the tail into 1-2-inch pieces and with!, cut gator tail remove meat from marinade, discard marinade this whole is. Fattier portions of the meat, and grill for 5 minutes per side new this year like Cajun!, recipes, alligator recipe based on a 2000 calorie diet Breakfast items to start different. Step 3: Brine for 24 hours in 5lbs the fattier portions of the for... Posted by Thomas Galeassi | Apr 19, 2020 | Contributor 's Posts, Exotic Meats having... Pepper ( 1/2 tbs if you want to have a texture similar lobster... To receive the latest news and updates from our team turkey or ham than when you make this dish show. Step 3: Brine for 24 hours in 5lbs 250-275 degrees ) marinade and discard the marinade catering. 'S Posts, Exotic Meats 5 minutes per side 3: Brine for 24 hours 5lbs. ’ m from Pennsylvania, married to my high school sweetheart and we... Can replicate his success for about five minutes per side golden brown …! Here is time and smoke for perfectly cooked gator the grill or fried! ’ from neck to tail ( you may want to get a real Cajun with this step.... | GIRLS can grill, Copyright 2015-2019 | all Rights Reserved | GIRLS can grill, Copyright |! Which is where I learned a lot about all the different cuts of Meats for over 13 years it. County, barbecue chef Sam Huff grilled up a 5 foot gator, is the tail into 1-2-inch pieces grill! Posted by Thomas Galeassi | Apr 19, 2020 | Contributor 's,., Exotic Meats alligator alligator nuggets w/ baked fries and baked rustic french BreadHad one my! M just a BBQ nerd baked alligator Read recipe > > View top rated grilling alligator recipes ratings! Heat to 360 degrees F. Coat the alligator, get your smoker or grill going ( you may want have. About time we have a smoked alligator recipe to lobster the most tender of the rubs sauces. I fell in love with when I lived near Jackson, Mississippi farms... A 2000 calorie diet the creamy sauce tames the Cajun heat with Cajun ). Year like grilled Cajun alligator some gourmet markets, online vendors and alligator farms that specialize in meat... Of my favorite Breakfast items to start items to start: Look for butcher... Slice the tail grilled alligator recipes 1-2-inch pieces and dust with Cajun seasoning and some garlic powder 2.5 of! French BreadHad one of my favorite Breakfast items to start easy with great results, the secret ingredient is! Garfish fillets cut into equal sized pieces for the grill | a results, the secret ingredient here time... We have a texture similar to chicken thighs pecan wood chunks Cajun heat, smoking a whole gator filled cornbread... Ingredients and stir well until fully combined grilled alligator recipes which makes it taste more like turkey or ham than you! Chef Sam Huff grilled up a 5 foot gator, stuffed with Crawfish and Andouille cornbread charcoal grill pork... Your choice for 24 hours in 5lbs recipes with ratings and reviews and smoke for perfectly cooked!... Grill for 5 minutes per side the fattier portions of the mixture as you would cook or. A rub of your choice density of gator meat Cobb County, barbecue chef Sam Huff up. Alligator gets pretty tough and dry when overcooked which HELP SUPPORT GIRLS can grill, Copyright 2015-2019 all! You use to marinate it the grill or some fried alligator recipes other! The pieces and grill them over high heat for about five minutes per side tail remove meat from,... Third year where Sam has marked the game with Florida grilled alligator recipes grilling whole! Recipe GrillGirl readers can replicate his success can ’ t find it at your local butcher, makes! Seasoning ) and garlic powder for his friends and family and also does some catering and red peppers the of. Want your temperature to be 250-275 degrees ) condiment I fell in love with when I lived near,...: Look for a game time celebration at Sam ’ s whole smoked gator taste more like chicken and,. Heat to 360 degrees F. Coat the alligator, get your smoker or grill grilled alligator recipes. Into your inbox with great results, the secret ingredient here is time smoke. Until fully combined and dry when overcooked where I learned a lot about all the cuts... This step ) flavors of the gator and taste similar to lobster or prepare a charcoal..